Tag Archives: writing

No matter what your parents thought, “Because I said so,” doesn’t make for a valid argument, though it may be a persuasive one. A claim, no matter how forcefully asserted, demands evidence. In fact, the more absolute the claim, the more compelling the evidence must be. Otherwise, all you have is an assertion. Evidence, often referred to as grounds or data, turns an unsupported assertion into a persuasive argument. Evidence makes a claim true or valid. Fortunately for those of us who like to make grand claims, evidence can be found everywhere.   FACTUAL Facts are certainly persuasive… who can argue with hard data or cold reality? All of history, science, and art lie waiting to support the right claims. Quantitative data can be especially compelling, as well as malleable. But avoid depending entirely on factual evidence; a truly effective argument appeals not only to the head but also to…

Read more

The classic argument—meaning the persuasive framework of statements and evidence as opposed to the kind where you argue with some jerk in the street over a parking spot that was clearly yours—often comes across as a tangle of premises and conclusions, syllogisms and fallacies. These rhetorical constructs often obscure the fundamentals of just getting a point across. Fortunately, British philosopher and educator Stephen Edelston Toulmin offered a simple way to describe the elements of arguments. Touliman’s model distills a practical argument down to three essentials: claims, evidence, and warrants. Every argument must start with a claim. Call it a proposition, position, or hypothesis, but the claim is a definitive statement that underlies the thesis of the argument and demands support.   “Summer is the best season of the year.”   This claim, free of qualifiers or exceptions, stakes a strong but surely disputable position. This is important, because any claim…

Read more

Almost a decade ago, the creators of both the SAT and ACT introduced essays to their previously pristine multiple-choice exams. Each organization charted a different course, differing in what the essays are written on, how long students have to write, and, perhaps most importantly, whether students are even required to write the essay. Considering that the College Board is moving towards a longer optional essay, it’s fair to say the ACT model won that particular competition. That said, one more aspect of the ACT essay infrastructure deserves recognition and further consideration from that other testing authority. While both organizations assign students 2-12 essay scores through a similar grading process, ACT provides additional context for performance in the form of stock essay comments. These essay comments, derived from the ACT scoring rubric, are selected by one of the two essay readers for inclusion on the student score report. Code numbers corresponding…

Read more

21/21